nuclear-news

The News That Matters about the Nuclear Industry Fukushima Chernobyl Mayak Three Mile Island Atomic Testing Radiation Isotope

Omigawd – a little bit of integrity creeping into the nuclear “debate”!

I hasten to reassure worthy political, industry, and media leaders, that this little aberration in the current gung ho pro-nuclear enthusiasm is nothing vitally and forcefully upsetting. After all, it comes only from a couple of boring old Baronesses, and an old retired HM Chief Inspector of Nuclear Installations. No doubt all three are just trying to look as though they’re still relevant, in this progressive modern period. These three have raised questions about the British government’s chummy relationship with the nuclear industry,

Now look – it really is “All Systems Go” for the global nuclear industry. We hardly need to consider Russia, as for the Kremlin, nuclear industry expansion has long been a top policy, and the public there don’t get a look in on nuclear decisions. China is a different and more complex story, as government and public are most supportive of renewable energy growth, while still pursuing some new nuclear projects.

In the West, the push for a new ‘nuclear renaissance’ is well and truly underway, and thanks to quite superb media management by the nuclear industry, public opinion seems all for it. In the USA, a network of donors, advocates, investors, and industry leaders  has run a sophisticated, well-funded campaign to change public perceptions and government policies on nuclear power. Much of this apparent groundswell of support for nuclear energy can be traced back to what we can call the pro-nuclear network (PNN): a relatively small, interconnected cluster of people and organizations with influence, wealth, and nuclear industry ties, who have played a singular role in jump-starting this surge. This has been documented in detail by THE COMMITTEE TO BRIDGE THE GAP. These writers have really done their homework on the sources behind the prevailing pro-nuclear opinion.

When it comes to Europe, the picture is more complex, with differing perspectives between the 27 member states. However, overall there is a clear trend in favour of nuclear energy, seen as safer now, and as an important tool against climate change. I am assuming that the same sort of pro nuclear persuasion is behind the trend.

So we come to the UK, where there still is some real debate about this industry. That is largely because of those pesky anti-progress Scots, who are forever making a nuisance of themselves. The British nuclear industry has had to tighten things up.

The previous chancellor Rachel Reeves had written an open letter calling for a nuclear sector-wide reset, with the sponsor department of the Office of Nuclear Regulation being the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP). Baroness Jo Valentine queried that, so it was changed to the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (Desnz). Baroness Thérèse Coffey then asked:

“… what safety protections are in place for the functioning independence of the Office for Nuclear Regulation after its transfer to the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, recognising that as it is not a non-ministerial department, ministerial directions can be issued.”

In response to the open letter from the Chancellor calling for a nuclear sector-wide reset… Leaders from across the UK nuclear industry have come together to set out how the sector will drive a fundamental change in culture, They set up  the Nuclear Industry CEO Forum led by the Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR), that unites senior leaders from across industry, government, and regulation to drive a sector-wide culture and reform agenda.

The Forum sent a letter to the Chancellor John Healey on 12 November, “the first time industry and regulators have come together to respond collectively to the chancellor’s call for reform.” The letter  called for “Urgent, system-wide reform… ensuring we work together to build the nuclear capacity we need at pace.”

The letter was signed by ONR chief executive and chief nuclear inspector Mike Finnerty and listed as being “On behalf of The UK Nuclear Industry CEO Forum.”

The other signatories were from:

  • AWE (the Atomic Weapons Establishment) Nuclear Security Technologies
  • Babcock International Group, including Cavendish Nuclear
  • BAE Systems Submarines
  • Great British Energy – Nuclear
  • NNB Genco (Hinkley Point C)
  • Nuclear Decommissioning Authority
  • Nuclear Restoration Services
  • Rolls-Royce SMR (small modular reactor)
  • Rolls-Royce Submarines
  • Sellafield Ltd
  • Sizewell C Ltd
  • UK National Nuclear Laboratory

Sam Harbison, former Health and Safety Executive (HSE) Nuclear Installations Inspectorate chief inspector told New Civil Engineer:

“I feel very uncomfortable with the ONR sending a letter to the government on behalf of the CEOs of the UK’s private nuclear industry.

“I feel that it undermines the separation between promotion and regulation that is regarded internationally as the building block for ensuring safety in licensed nuclear activities.

“I don’t believe that the regulator can have a shared purpose with the industry that it is regulating.”

Mmmmm… this sort of thing is probably happening all over the world wherever there’s a nuclear industry. Too much money at risk, too many jobs depending on it. Those criticisms by backward-looking old fogies might not make an impact, but at least they’re showing a bit of integrity.

November 22, 2026 - Posted by | Christina's notes

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.