A crack in the AUKUS public relations pressure hull!

by Rex Patrick | Oct 5, 2025 , https://michaelwest.com.au/a-crack-in-the-aukus-pr-pressure-hull/

AUKUS is a hugely expensive Defence project facing considerable and, many argue, insurmountable hurdles. But does Defence have a Plan B? Rex Patrick reveals a crack in Defence PR’s high tensile pressure hull steel.

There has to be an AUKUS Plan B, surely. So MWM FOI’ed the Australian Submarine Agency (ASA) to find out.

Hit ‘em with your Talking Points.

In response, the ASA partially released one document showing ‘talking points’ that had been given to the Project lead, Vice Admiral Jonathon Mead, in case he was asked about the US’s AUKUS review.

At first glance, MWM thought that the ASA’s back-up plan to defend the Nation was to

“roll out some talking points to fire at an approaching enemy.“

roll out some talking points to fire at an approaching enemy.

But a closer look revealed more.

A Crack in the Submarine Pressure Hull

The talking points weren’t the only documents.

Despite the public bravado, the FOI decision shows that there is some discussion going on behind the scenes.

There were three more documents that met the terms of MWM’s request. The decision letter reveals that the Government has been discussing with our AUKUS partners, and internally, on what to do if it all goes to hell in a nuclear handbasket.

Self-confidence Bluster Exposed

The ASA has claimed the documents are sensitive (something we’ll push back on with an appeal), and so we can’t see the exact details of what’s being said.

But we know there are conversations taking place.

“That’s a good thing.“

1×1515

1:36 / 2:23

Listen to this story

2 min

AUKUS is a hugely expensive Defence project facing considerable and, many argue, insurmountable hurdles. But does Defence have a Plan B? Rex Patrick reveals a crack in Defence PR’s high tensile pressure hull steel.

There has to be an AUKUS Plan B, surely. So MWM FOI’ed the Australian Submarine Agency (ASA) to find out.

FOI Asking about a Plan B

Hit ‘em with your Talking Points.

In response, the ASA partially released one document showing ‘talking points’ that had been given to the Project lead, Vice Admiral Jonathon Mead, in case he was asked about the US’s AUKUS review.

US AUKUS Review talking Points (Source: Defence)

At first glance, MWM thought that the ASA’s back-up plan to defend the Nation was to

roll out some talking points to fire at an approaching enemy.

But a closer look revealed more.

A Crack in the Submarine Pressure Hull

The talking points weren’t the only documents.

Despite the public bravado, the FOI decision shows that there is some discussion going on behind the scenes.

More Documents about Plan B (Source: Defence)

There were three more documents that met the terms of MWM’s request. The decision letter reveals that the Government has been discussing with our AUKUS partners, and internally, on what to do if it all goes to hell in a nuclear handbasket.

Plan B Talk Going On (Source: Defence)

Self-confidence Bluster Exposed

The ASA has claimed the documents are sensitive (something we’ll push back on with an appeal), and so we can’t see the exact details of what’s being said.

But we know there are conversations taking place.

That’s a good thing.

Greens Senator David Shoebridge, commenting on the FOI decision, said, “Labor has managed to combine two of their worst behaviours in one go here, using exemptions in FOI to refuse to release documents while secretly doubling down on a plan B for AUKUS. I don’t think treating the Australian public like mushrooms is a viable long-term political strategy for Albanese”.

It’s Senate Estimates this coming week. The Coalition is a unity cheer squad with Labor when it comes to AUKUS, so we won’t see them probing hard on a Plan B. Hopefully, Shoebridge will squeeze some more out of Defence, at least until MWM’s FOI appeal is finalised.

For now, at least, we now know the ASA’s public AUKUS bluster is a deception. They’re not so confident after all.

Rex Patrick

Rex Patrick is a former Senator for South Australia and, earlier, a submariner in the armed forces. Best known as an anti-corruption and transparency crusader, Rex is also known as the “Transparency Warrior.”