nuclear-news

The News That Matters about the Nuclear Industry Fukushima Chernobyl Mayak Three Mile Island Atomic Testing Radiation Isotope

Tucker “Gets It” – Putin Doesn’t Want American Missiles on His Border

Much as I hate siding with the Right Wing, and much as if I were an American, I would probably be a Democrat, I have to admit that Tucker Carlson and Fox News sometimes make a bit of sense.

It pains me to have to side with these Right-wingers.

But we are at a point where it is more important to THINK. And America’s Democrats don’t seem able to think. Indeed, Americans seem to slavishly follow the mindset of their political parties. And thinking seems to be an activity that is somehow treachersous.

The Unz Review, MIKE WHITNEY • DECEMBER 27, 2022

“Getting Ukraine to join NATO was the key to inciting war with Russia. We didn’t get it at the time. (But) Now it’s obvious. Vladimir Putin invaded Ukraine because he didn’t want Ukraine to join NATO. Putin certainly had other motives as well; people always do, but that’s the main reason Russia invaded. The Russians don’t want American missiles on their border. They don’t want a hostile government next door. Now that is true, whether you are allowed to say it aloud in public or not. It has been true for a long time. A lot has been written about this over many years by serious people. No one who knows anything and is honest, will tell you Putin invaded Ukraine simply because he is evil. Putin may be evil, he certainly seems to be, but he also has strategic motives for doing that, whether you agree with those motives or not. That is irrelevant. Those are the facts.” Tucker Carlson, Fox News

Tucker Carlson is right about Ukraine. NATO membership for Ukraine was clearly a provocation aimed at luring Russia into an invasion. And, it worked, too. Putin could not take the risk of having “a hostile government next door” or “American missiles on his border,” so he acted to preempt those threats by sending the tanks across the border on Febrary 24, 2021.

Where Carlson is a little off-base, is when he he says that Putin’s actions were prompted by “strategic motives”. That’s not really wrong, it just misses the point. The point is that Washington’s combat troops and missile sites on Russia’s western border would pose a grave threat to Russia’s national security. Putin would have to be out-of-his-mind to allow a development like that. So, he did what any American president would have done if he had been in the same situation. He invaded. This is an excerpt from an article at the World Socialist Web Site:

The narrative in the media, which presents the invasion as an unprovoked action, is a fabrication that conceals the aggressive actions by the NATO powers, in particular the United States, and its puppets in the Ukrainian government.

In Europe and Asia, the US pursued a strategy aimed at encircling and subjugating Russia. Directly violating its earlier promises that the Soviet bureaucracy and Russian oligarchy were delusional enough to believe, NATO has expanded to include almost all major countries in Eastern Europe, apart from Ukraine and Belarus.

In 2014, the US orchestrated a far-right coup in Kiev that overthrew a pro-Russian government that had opposed Ukrainian membership in NATO. In 2018, the US officially adopted a strategy of preparing for “great power conflict” with Russia and China. In 2019, it unilaterally withdrew from the INF Treaty, which banned the deployment of intermediate-range nuclear missiles. Preparations for war with Russia and the arming of Ukraine were at the center of the Democrats’ first attempt to impeach Donald Trump in 2019.” (“The US-Ukrainian Strategic Partnership of November 2021 and the Russian invasion of Ukraine“, World Socialist Web Site)

This is a brief but excellent summary of events leading up to the Russian invasion on February 24, 2021. Putin and his advisors had been following developments in Ukraine with growing alarm after it became apparent that their worst fears were materializing. The CIA was not only arming and training paramilitaries in the east in preparation for a war against ethnic Russians in the Donbas, the US was also cultivating an explicitly anti-Russia political party –which contained openly fascist elements– that was designated to implement Washington’s proxy-war strategy. In short, the US fanned the flames of ethnic hatred in order to lay the groundwork for its “Great Power” conflagration with Moscow. Here’s more from the WSWS:……………………………………………………

For Russia, Ukraine’s membership in NATO was “the reddest of red lines”. Since the end of WW2, NATO had expanded from 12 to 30 countries almost all of which pushed further eastward towards Russia’s western border. When the United States indicated it would seek NATO membership for Ukraine at the Bucharest Summit in 2008, Putin’s response was uncharacteristically ferocious………………………………………..

The point we’re making is that the current conflict has nothing to do with claims that Putin is “an aspiring imperialist longing to reconstruct the Soviet empire.” There is no evidence for that at all. The real issue is NATO expansion and, in particular, the secret agreements between the United States and Ukraine that made Ukraine a full-fledged member of NATO in everything but name. Take a look at this excerpt from an article by Marcy Winograd :

The September, 2021, Joint Statement on the U.S.-Ukraine Strategic Partnership reaffirmed Ukraine as a de facto NATO partner,……………………………………………………………….

Brilliant analysis, and right to the point. Ukraine didn’t need to be formally entered into NATO because the US stealthily bestowed defacto membership on them out of the public eye. Naturally, Putin and his lieutenants knew what was going on, but the media made sure that everyone else remained in the dark. And all of this sleight-of-hand was going on just months before Putin was forced to invade. It’s actually shocking.

Does it sound like Ukraine snuck into NATO through the back door?

It does.

This summary helps to show that Ukraine’s non-membership in NATO is largely “a fiction.” Ukraine has been fully-integrated into the anti-Russia Alliance in every way except formal approval. Ukraine’s Strategic Partnership with the US, which was signed by both parties in 2021, underscores this point. It also helps “to clarify” –as Marcy Winograd notes– “that the United States and NATO provoked the war.” Indeed, Washington has put a significant amount of time and energy into a project that is aimed at crossing all of Russia’s redlines, directly challenging Russia’s basic security interests, and forcing Russia to invade a neighboring country. Simply put, Washington placed a gun to Russia’s head and threatened to pull the trigger.

Fortunately, Putin responded in the way that best ensured the safety and security of his own government, his own country, and his own people. We would expect any responsible leader to do the same. https://www.unz.com/mwhitney/tucker-gets-it-putin-doesnt-want-american-missiles-on-his-borde

Advertisement

December 29, 2022 - Posted by | Uncategorized

6 Comments »

  1. Carlsons good friend in congress, Marjorie Greene just came on record saying America should bomb mexico and nuke China. Hopefully, you would come to understand that partisan politics don’t mean much in the evil empire usa anymore. There are millions of homeless and starving in the usa. People cannot afford rent or food or gas.. So many people on foot with bedrolls. Young, old, all ethnicities . Worse than the great depression of 1929 to 1940, my great grandmother described.

    The bipartisan congress just approved 1.1 trillion dollars for the pentagon(868 plus more for ukraine), billions for for police to beat up and oppression the homeless and poor, billions for more prisons and jails. Carlson is a fascist who, supports putting a lot more poor and black people in prison. He supports nuke war with China There is now a bipartisan project of facist republicans and, phoney corporate warmonger democrats, to consolidate a genuine authoritarian police state.

    By far and above the largest group of people in the usa, are the disposessed, poor, working people Young people and people of color whose ability to vote and voting rights are restricted. The majority is not the frikin fascist repuklican, echo chambers we are bombarded w 24/7 in all media . The charlatans that u choose to parrot . The facist political comittees that pays bloggers, hacks and infuencers improve its image. The majority of people in the usa are welloff corporate democrat warmonger lackeys u hate in spite of the fact that u pushed for demon Biden as the best alternative .

    There is so much paid propaganda in the news and on the internet it’s not worth viewing how can an intelligent person could be suked ,into partisan politics as rotten, corrupt and undemocratic as they are in the usa? 70 percent of americans are against been the demon giving anymore money to the criminals in ukraine

    Comment by Edie tomlic | December 29, 2022 | Reply

    • To Edie tomlic: “Carlson is a fascist ….”. I do not disagree with what you say here. But what I am trying to do is to get to the facts, to the truth. On this occasion, Carlson said what is needed to be said – “Getting Ukraine to join NATO was the key to inciting war with Russia.”. I cannot swallow the prevailing Western lie that it’s a great idea to sacrifice Ukraine in the American cause of weakening Russia. Carlson spelt out the truth. It is a great shame that the supposedly “good” Democrats obscure the real reasons for this war. As I stated before – It pains me to have to side with these Right-wingers.

      Comment by Christina Macpherson | December 29, 2022 | Reply

  2. Carlson doesn’t care that Americans are starving and hurting. Neither do democrats. So what , he mouths the same crap he has always mouthed. He hates poor and working people. The majority of people are not Democrat or republican in the usa. The majority are screwed. Carlson appeals to his insect captive white supremecist audience. They are not likely to change the proxy war. If the world does survive the fascist nato democrats. proxy WAR Carlson and its cohorts will get ther rich corporate facist little brother and sister democrats to start ww3 w China. This is the WAY neoliberal empires that comit to fascism wrk . Why not publish real criticism of the proxy war like black agenda report

    Comment by Edie tomlic | December 29, 2022 | Reply

    • to Edie tomlic. OK. Well, where do I find this black agenda report? I’m sure that Carlson doesn’t care. However, he is, unfortunately, an influential voice. And in the present crises, I have to welcome any influential voice that happens to say something sensible – at least when they say something sensible.

      Comment by Christina Macpherson | December 29, 2022 | Reply


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: