nuclear-news

The News That Matters about the Nuclear Industry Fukushima Chernobyl Mayak Three Mile Island Atomic Testing Radiation Isotope

France’s heavily subsidised nuclear industry – a costly warning to USA

The French nuclear program has been a state-owned monopoly from the outset, heavily subsidized by the government.  It could not survive in a free market.  By copying the French model – both in its energy choices and its willingness to use public funds to subsidize an industry that has never been self-sustaining – the U.S. is heading down a dangerous path of nuclear socialism.

France’s Nuclear “Miracle” is More Fantasy that Fact,  The Hill, By Mark Cooper – 09/23/10 Among backers of nuclear power development in the U.S., France has long been held out as the model to emulate. Now, as pressure builds on policy makers in Washington to set a new domestic energy course, the French experience once again is being heralded as proof that nuclearpower is the way to go.
Trouble is, France’s nuclear “miracle” is more fantasy than fact.  And facts are what Congress – and the American public – deserve before massive public subsidies are committed for new reactor construction.
Here are some key findings from my analysis of what has mistakenly been called the French “nuclear miracle.”

*Nuclear reactors are not cheaper in France.  Nuclear power backers claim France has solved the problem of cost of new reactor construction through standardization and efficiencies of scale.
That is untrue. French reactors have escalated in price at almost the same rate as those in the U.S.
Consider two French construction projects now underway, one in Flamanville on the Normandy coast, and the other in Finland. Both are years behind schedule and billions of dollars over budget.  The troublesome reactor design that’s causing these problems has been proposed for construction on the Chesapeake Bay and is a leading candidate for a multi-billion-dollar U.S. loan guarantee. Even before ground is broken here, the projected cost of France’s design is well above the average for other reactor designs.

In the U.S., projections of the cost of reactor construction have tripled over the past decade. The implication of this price volatility has not escaped Wall Street. All of the U.S. utilities that have sought a nuclear construction license have seen their credit ratings downgraded.
Four-fifths of those license applications have ultimately been suspended or delayed – in large part due to the uncertainties of cost, shrinking demand for new generating capacity or the availability of private credit.

*Nuclear reactors crowd out energy efficiency efforts and renewable energy investments.  The French track record on energy efficiency and renewable energy is poor compared to similar European nations.  In France, commitment to huge nuclear reactors has led to excess generating
capacity which, in turn, has discouraged efficiency…..
By copying the French model and pouring billions into new nuclear construction, the U.S. would siphon off available public funds for proven, cost-effective and environmentally responsible renewable generating capacity.

The French nuclear program has been a state-owned monopoly from the outset, heavily subsidized by the government.  It could not survive in a free market.  By copying the French model – both in its energy choices and its willingness to use public funds to subsidize an industry that has never been self-sustaining – the U.S. is heading down a dangerous path of nuclear socialism.

Far from holding up the French experience as a model of success, U.S. policy makers should be pointing to it as proof that a massive public commitment to nuclear power is NOT the best course for the U.S.  And it certainly is not where billions in taxpayer dollars should be committed. Money can’t and won’t solve the inherent problems that have plagued nuclear power from the beginning – both here and, most notably, in France.

France’s Nuclear “Miracle” is More Fantasy that Fact – The Hill’s Congress Blog

September 24, 2010 - Posted by | business and costs, France | , , , , , ,

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: