Inquiry urges Australian gov’t to terminate AUKUS pact.

Source: Xinhua, Editor: huaxia, 2026-11-04, https://english.news.cn/20261104/e47195ed31584f15a2214df618abf5c9/c.html
CANBERRA, Nov. 4 (Xinhua) — An independent inquiry has called for the Australian government to immediately terminate the AUKUS treaty, describing the pact as the riskiest defense decision in national history.
Former government minister Peter Garrett and former Australian Defense Force chief Chris Barrie, two of the five commissioners conducting the public inquiry into AUKUS, presented the final report at the National Press Club of Australia in Canberra on Wednesday, concluding that the landmark security pact does not serve Australia well and should be scrapped.
After receiving more than 1,000 submissions and conducting 10 days of public hearings around the country, the final report said that the inquiry did not uncover any “convincing foundations” for AUKUS.
“We concluded that AUKUS is the worst, riskiest and most costly defense decision ever made by an Australian government,” the report said.
“AUKUS jeopardizes our sovereignty, further entangles us with U.S. war planning and actually endangers our security.”
The report made 16 recommendations, including that Australia immediately terminate pillar one of the AUKUS deal, under which Australia would acquire eight nuclear-powered submarines in the 2030s and 2040s, due to current delivery schedules “most likely” being unachievable.
Additionally, it said that plans for a U.S. naval base near Perth in Western Australia should be suspended until “critical questions” regarding nuclear security and health and environmental safety for the local population are fully examined.
The independent inquiry was established after successive federal governments ruled out holding a major public review of the pact.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese told reporters on Tuesday after meeting with British counterpart Andy Burnham in the Caribbean that work on AUKUS is progressing very well.■
With Rumors of Nuclear War, the New Congress must end the Iran conflict to avoid a U.S. Catastrophe

Juan Cole 11/03/2026, https://www.juancole.com/2026/11/congress-conflict-catastrophe.html
Ann Arbor (Informed Comment) – However the midterms turn out, the 120th Congress must cut off money to Trump for his ongoing Iran War. As an unresolved geopolitical issue, it threatens the future of the United States like no other issue.
In mid-September, Senate Republicans voted to allow Trump to continue his war on Iran, after several GOP House members had joined the Democrats in invoking the War Powers Act.
If Michiganders want a reason to vote against Mike Rogers for Senate, they just have to consider that Rogers would give Trump anything he wanted on the Iran War front. Rogers called the Iran War a “win-win-win” for the US. So much winning. He has flip-flopped now that high gasoline and diesel prices, caused by Trump’s attack on Iran, have made the GOP about as welcome in the voting booth as a skunk at an office party. He says he wants to see the war “wound down.” But would he vote to deny Trump the money to continue to prosecute the war? I wouldn’t bet the farm on it.
Since February 28, when Israel’s Benjamin Netanyahu and Donald Trump murdered dozens of high Iranian officials from the air, including the clerical leader Ali Khamenei, and initiated 13,000 strikes against Iranian targets with no provocation, the world has been on a knife edge.
We only avoided a global recession because China deeply cut its petroleum imports, from 11.5 million barrels a day to under 9 million barrels a day, releasing instead massive amounts of oil from both private and government strategic petroleum reserves. The US and Europe also released petroleum from reserves. These maintained enough oil on the market to keep prices of Brent crude around an average of $96 a barrel, which is a drag on the economy but not an existential crisis. The price averaged $69 a barrel in 2025, though, so the Iran War has had an inflationary impact that many ordinary families in the US and around the world are feeling.
But the war isn’t over. On Monday, the US military staged several strikes on Iran’s Qeshm island. Iran continues to report that tankers in the Persian Gulf have struck mines as they attempted to transit the Strait of Hormuz, though many observers believe the ships are more likely to have been hit by drones than to have struck mines. There may not be any Iranian mines remaining.
Then the prominent conservative commentator Tucker Carlson warned that outgoing Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has been urging Trump to drop nuclear bombs on Iran. One doesn’t know what to make of this allegation, which Netanyahu’s office has denied. On the one hand, Carlson is well connected in Washington among people close to Trump, since he used to be in that camp himself. On the other hand, pundits make their living on the internet by seeking clicks and eyeballs, which sometimes drives them to sensationalism.
But this kind of report is as serious as a heart attack. And, let’s face it. Is there really any doubt that Netanyahu is capable of trying to get the US to nuke Iran? No, no there is not. And is there really any doubt that Trump is stupid enough to fall for this attempt to manipulate him? No, no there is not. So what Carlson is saying has to be taken seriously. Very seriously.
Submission to AUKUS Public Inquiry -Australia should quit alliance with the UK and US – Dr Gideon Maxwell Polya.

No.258
“……………………My submission is in 3 parts and summarizes several detailed articles that set out why
Australia should quit alliance with the UK and US.
(A). As a UK lackey, US lackey or major climate criminal country Australia has
violated all circa 80 Indo-Pacific countries.
In 2021 Australia formed the anti-China AUKUS (Australia, UK and US) Alliance and
thence the Quad (Australia, India, US and Japan) Alliance to contain a supposedly
aggressive China. In reality as a nuclear terrorist, climate criminal, serial invader
and subversive entity Australia has violated all Indo-Pacific countries (see Gideon
Polya, “AUKUS & Quad In Context: Australia Violates All Indo-Pacific countries”,
Countercurrents, 9 December 2021: https://countercurrents.org/2021/12/aukus-qu
ad-in-context-australia-violates-all-indo-pacific-countries/ and for an exhaustively
referenced version see Gideon Polya, “Australia violates all Indo-Pacific countries”,
Stop state terrorism, 9 December 2021: https://sites.google.com/site/stopstateterr
orism/2021-12-09-australia-violates-all-indo-pacific-countries ).
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………As a UK and thence US lackey, Australia in the last 80 years (i.e. WW2 onwards)
has had armed forces in many countries of the Indo-Pacific region, and has joined
the US in massive invasions and occupations. Australia has participated in all
post-1950 US Asian Wars (atrocities in which 40 million Asians have died from
violence and war-imposed deprivation). Anti-Arab anti-Semitic Australia has been
an enthusiastic participant in the US War on Terror (over 30 million Muslims have
died from violence and imposed deprivation in 20 countries invaded by the US
Alliance since the US Government-exploited 9/11 atrocity that killed 3,000 people).
The joint US-Australian telecommunications spying base at Pine Gap in Central
Australia targets war criminal US drone strikes on 7 Muslim countries.
As US lackeys Australians have been involved with the US in covert subversion of
many Indo-Pacific countries, and were successful in achieving regime change in 8
instances, namely Laos (1960), Indonesia (1965), Cambodia (1970), Chile (1973),
Australia (1975), Fiji (1987), Fiji (2000), and Australia (2010) (the latter 3 also
involving Apartheid Israel). Australia is second only to the US as a fervent
supporter of nuclear terrorist, genocidally racist, grossly human rights-abusing and
globally subversive Apartheid Israel, and hence of the utterly vile and intolerable
crime of Apartheid…………………………………………………………………………………………………
(B). Why Australia should quit military links with serial war criminal, genocidally
racist and egregiously mendacious America.
For a detailed and exhaustively referenced analysis see Gideon Polya, “Why
Australia Should Quit Military Links With Serial War Criminal America”,
Countercurrents, 28 January 2023: https://countercurrents.org/2023/01/why-austr
alia-should-quit-military-links-with-serial-war-criminal-america/ . Summarized
below are cogent arguments why Australia should quit its AUKUS alliance with
nuclear terrorist, genocidally racist and serial war criminal America and the UK.
(1). War typically violates International law, and is the penultimate in repugnant
racism, with genocide being the ultimate in racism…………………………………………..
(2). The US is a horrendous serial invader of other countries. Apart from inevitable
border spats, most countries in the world have not invaded other countries…………………………………………………
(3). War criminal active and passive mass murder by nuclear terrorist America and
the US Alliance. Iraq and Afghanistan were not the only countries murderously
violated by the US in the 21st century. It was estimated in 2015 that 32 million
Muslims had died from violence (5 million) and imposed deprivation (27 million) in
20 countries invaded by the US Alliance after the US Government-exploited 9/11
atrocity that killed 3,000 people, mostly innocent Americans…………………………………………………
(4) American lying ………………………… As cogently analysed by
Professors Edward Herman and Noam Chomsky in “Manufacturing Consent”,
mendacious US Mainstream media serve the interests of the US Establishment and
US governments.
(5). America violates, subverts, dirties and acutely threatens Australia.
(i). Australia was involved in all post-1950 US Asian wars.
(ii). AUKUS and Australian violation of all Indo-Pacific countries.
(iii). Australian involvement in 8 US-effected coups.
(iv). US lackey Australia’s deadly covert operations in neighbouring Indonesia.
(v). The US Murdoch media empire dominates Australia.
(vi). America spies on, subverts, deceives and betrays Australia.
(vii). UK- , US-, and Zionist-backed coups and other subversive interventions in
Australia.
(viii). Craven submission to American militarism makes Australia complicit in
nuclear terrorism and makes Australia a prime nuclear target.
(ix). Zionist subversion of IHRA member Australia is a product of blind Australian
fealty to Zionist-subverted America and soils Australia.
(x). Locked-in support for US militarism and militarist fiscal perversion inescapably
contributes to 100,000 preventable Australian deaths annually.
(xi). Australia is complicit in horrendous UK and US war crimes, notably in Iraq and
Afghanistan.
(xii). Blind support for the US has created a contemptible, reality-ignoring,
“look-the-other-way” Australian national culture.
(xiii). US lies and terror hysteria impacting Australian civil liberties.
(xiv). Genocidal US, US Alliance and Australia need de-Nazification.
(C). The AUKUS Alliance betrays, robs, soils, threatens and kills Australians.
………………………………… (i). AUKUS betrays Australians. The AUKUS deal supposedly protects Australian
sovereignty but the opposite is true. The nuclear submarines (if delivered) would
become Australia-crewed adjuncts to the naval strategy of a serial war-making US.
The deal locks an impotent Australia into US war-making strategy against our
biggest trading partner, China. Conversely, military strategy expert Albert Palazzo
(“The Big Fix”) argues that middle-power Australia should revert from a US-led
“strategic offensive” position to an efficient, effective and Australia-first “strategic
defensive” position. Our AUKUS partner, Zionist-perverted America, gets Australia
to hugely subsidize US war industry, makes Australia a prime nuclear target, and
substitutes hugely expensive, submarine hunting , White Elephant “sitting ducks”
for an intelligent, multi-faceted and high technology defence system.
(ii). AUKUS robs Australians. The Australia Institute estimates that the cost could
be $500 billion for a few second-hand, US-controlled, US-assisting, single-purpose
submarines that may already be detectable and vulnerable to the latest
AI-assisted anti-submarine technology. The US war industry gets A$500 billion and
in return Australia becomes a prime nuclear target, and gets locked into an absurd
“strategic offensive” position for the benefit of the US instead of an expert-advised
“strategic defensive” position for the defence of Australia.
(iii). AUKUS soils Australia. Racism is vile because to whom we are born and by
whom we are raised is out of our control. War is the penultimate in racism and
genocide the ultimate. The UK has invaded 193 countries or nearly every country.
Only 3 countries have not had a US military presence. Before WW2 the British
committed genocide on all inhabited continents whereas the US (African slavery
and Pacific islands aside) largely confined itself to the American Indian genocide
and domination of Latin America. After WW2 the UK replaced colonialism with
deadly neo-colonialism but also participated in the (deaths from violence and
deprivation in brackets) Palestinian (3 million), Korean (5 million), Iraqi (5 million), Libyan (0.2 million) and Afghan (7 million) Genocides. The US invaded a swathe of
countries around the world after WW2…………………………………………………………………….
(iv). AUKUS threatens Australians. The Australia-US joint spying base at Pine Gap,
Central Australia, plays a key role US nuclear terrorism and in targeting US and
Israeli bombing. Australia is constructing a huge base for nuclear-armed US
submarines in Western Australia, is expanding the Tindal air base in the Northern
Territory to host potentially nuclear-armed B-52 bombers, and hosts a
3,000-personnel US Marine base near Darwin. AUKUS makes Australia a prime
nuclear target – in any escalating nuclear war key bases in Australia and Australian
cities would be bombed before bombing any US cities………………………………………………….
(v). AUKUS will kill Australians. AUKUS will remove $500 billion from Australia’s
capacity to keep Australians alive and healthy via its prosperous economy-based
world-leading universal health care system, the National Disability Insurance
Scheme (NDIS), the education system, and preventive medicine…………………………………………………………. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1s1_Y3ywvk8ywqTLFvhOt3RfBFZfYH25g/view
Iran’s nuclear bomb debate gains ground on official platforms

Calls to revise Iran’s nuclear doctrine and build an atomic bomb are
gaining prominence on official platforms after gathering momentum in
hardline circles, although the country’s top security official says no
policy change has been approved.
Mohsen Rezaei, secretary of Iran’s
Supreme National Security Council, said on Saturday, October 31, that
neither the government nor the broader establishment had made a new
decision on changing the country’s nuclear doctrine. However, he
acknowledged discussion of whether Iran should retain its existing policy
if war resumes. Rezaei said attacks on Iran’s nuclear facilities had
prompted public demands for reconsidering the policy. He argued that Iran
had cooperated fully with International Atomic Energy Agency inspections.
Iran International 2nd Nov 2026, https://www.iranintl.com/en/202611015457
Hegseth Fires Pentagon’s Top War Planner

Over two dozen high-ranking generals and admirals have been dismissed or have quit since Hegseth was named war secretary
October 30, 2026, https://thecradle.co/articles/hegseth-fires-pentagons-top-war-planner-amid-preparations-to-reignite-war-on-iran
US Secretary of War Pete Hegseth ousted Army Lieutenant General Brett Sylvia, who was responsible for drafting military options for war against Iran, The Atlantic reported on 28 October.
Sylvia is the second officer dismissed from the Joint Staff’s top strategy and planning post this year, and he was removed without explanation, with no replacement named.
The general’s removal marks at least the 26th dismissal of a general or admiral since Hegseth assumed office in January 2025, and comes as US President Donald Trump weighs renewed escalation against Iran once the US midterm elections conclude on 3 November.
“We may do another little Epic Fury,” Trump told supporters at a rally last week, referring to the name given to the US-Israeli joint assault on Iran launched in February, “Or they’ll agree.”
Washington has since warned its Gulf allies to expect a “short, intense” attack on Iran after the midterms, passing the message through diplomatic and military channels, the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) reported on 28 October, citing people briefed on the exchanges.
US Central Command (CENTCOM), which is directing the war, has drawn up options ranging from a brief wave of strikes on Iran’s nuclear sites to a prolonged campaign designed to push Iran’s economy toward collapse and force Tehran into negotiations.
Sylvia’s ouster is the latest in a sweeping campaign to purge the US military’s command structure of officers on the basis of political loyalty to Trump and his administration rather than merit.
Among those removed was Defense Intelligence Agency director Lieutenant General Jeffrey Kruse, who was fired after his agency reportedly assessed that the June 2025 US strikes had only delayed Iran’s nuclear program, contradicting Trump’s own claims of absolute success.
Others have reportedly been pushed out over past ties to diversity policies that Hegseth dismisses as “woke,” a label he has used to justify the cuts.
Senator Mark Kelly, a former Navy combat pilot, has called the firings a “purge” that will take the military years to recover from.
AUKUS has escaped proper scrutiny for five years. That is about to change

Doug Cameron, Former Federal Senator for New South Wales, October 26, 2026
The independent public inquiry into AUKUS will report on 4 November after examining the project’s implications for Australia’s security, economy, sovereignty and international standing.
Five years on from the announcement of AUKUS, a project founded on subterfuge and evasion, the public inquiry into AUKUS will launch its report at the National Press Club in Canberra on 4 November. This inquiry has gone where both the Coalition and the ALP have failed to go. It has revealed the depth and breadth of this project for Australia’s national security, economy and international credibility.
I am proud to have been part of the Inquiry Secretariat providing support to our eminent and talented team of inquiry commissioners. In my view it is now clear that AUKUS is about militarising Australia in the interests of the US, ensuring the grifters in defence and the arms industry are well fed. It is an act of self-harm and madness on the part of the Australian government.
The secrecy that lies at the heart of this $368 billion fiasco was maintained by federal or state governments that refused to appear before the public inquiry to make the case for the biggest transfer of sovereign wealth in Australia’s history. That is some kind of contempt for the Australian community.
To recap, if this project goes well it will result in the cost of $368 billion, plus over $120 billion to manage the weapons-grade nuclear waste. It will put at least four Australian cities in the cross-hairs in the event of a conflict between the US – now an international wrecking ball – and our largest trading partner, China.
That’s if these nuclear submarines ever materialise. AUKUS is looking increasingly like a distraction from the main game, which is about turning Australia into a compliant base for the US military.
Meanwhile the Australian government continues to dodge any accountability and simply responds to criticisms by muttering about protecting sea lanes and our alliance with the US. Meanwhile AUKUS critics have been variously accused of communism, appeasement and failing to understand ‘changed circumstances’.
The government’s determination to avoid any scrutiny reached absurd proportions when delegates to the ALP National Conference were denied the opportunity to debate AUKUS (and Palestine) at the national conference.
So, I was shocked to see that while federal and state governments are unwilling to have an honest conversation with the people funding this project, us, they were very forthcoming in the submissions the federal and South Australian governments gave to the UK Parliament through the UK defence committee inquiry.
Forelock tugging to the ‘mother country’ while denying Australians the right to government accountability on AUKUS is reprehensible, undemocratic and politically dumb.
Despite these submissions putting an unjustified gloss on AUKUS, and our almost pleading submissions, the UK defence committee has given our parliamentarians a masterclass in scrutiny, honesty and accountability.
Among the findings of this UK inquiry are that the alliances that have underpinned global security for decades can no longer be taken for granted; that even the UK public has little confidence in the project; that the investment pipeline is already faltering; and that the development of new SSN facilities in Adelaide and Perth could pose a risk to workforce retention at the UK’s equivalent facilities in Barrow-in-Furness and Plymouth.
The town critical to the delivery of the SSN-AUKUS, Barrow-in-Furness, is in dire need of total regeneration, with major issues of poverty, crime, alcohol and drug abuse and unemployment. Convincing the highly skilled workforce to move there is considered a huge challenge to the project. The report found this will require additional funding from central government to provide the investment in housing, healthcare, transport and education which the town urgently needs.
The AUKUS deal demands the UK increase port visits and later rotate an Astute-class submarine out of Australia to maintain credibility within AUKUS. But the UK report notes that the arrival of HMS Anson in Western Australia, while welcome, pushed the Astute class beyond its limits.
Nor did Pillar 2 escape criticism, with the report finding that progress to date has been disappointing and inadequate. It now faces an uphill battle to restore credibility. In the short term, the UK government must press for swift agreement within the trilateral on priority projects which provide tangible benefit to the “war fighter”, and their subsequent delivery at pace. It concludes the UK’s approach to Pillar 2 has so far been disjointed.
This was a report on the UK’s side of the agreement. This is the country we have committed over $4.5 billion to, and they are still struggling with almost every element of the project.
The scale of the problems in the UK further demonstrates that AUKUS is a defence, economic and social disaster for Australia. It is driven by naïve politicians, lobbyists, arms industry think tanks and a revolving door of retired politicians, public servants and military personnel.
Jargon such as “progressive patriotism”, “steady progress, all on track, historic opportunities, creating jobs”, beggars belief when compared with the faltering UK and US submarine industries that are destined to fail to deliver.
It is time for the Australian community to tell the Albanese government to stop treating all of us as mugs; enough is enough with this madness.
Israel’s elections: all roads lead to genocide
Analysts say Israel’s two main political blocs uphold ethnic cleansing policies against Palestinians and people of the region, while differences between them are only related to internal affairs.
Aseel Saleh, October 28 2026, https://breakthroughnews.org/2026/10/28/israels-elections-all-roads-lead-to-genocide/
Israelis headed to voting centers on Tuesday, October 27, in legislative elections to choose the members of the parliament, known as the Knesset.
The event marks Israel’s first general election since the October 7 attacks, which Netanyahu’s government expanded into a multi-front regional war.
Who is competing in the elections?
For many, these elections serve as a direct referendum on Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and the far-right bloc he heads.
The Pro-Netanyahu Bloc
This bloc comprises the National Liberal Party (Likud) led by Netanyahu, the Religious Zionist Party (HaTzionut HaDatit) led by current Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, and Jewish Power Party (Otzma Yehudit) led by National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir.
The coalition advocates for the consolidation of Israeli rule throughout the occupied Palestinian territories, explicitly rejects the possibility of Palestinian statehood, promotes the expansion of settlements and the implementation of hardline security measures against Palestinians. It also calls for disavowing the Oslo Accords, and the total disarmament of Hamas.
The anti-Netanyahu bloc
The primary competitor to Netanyahu and his coalition is the bloc led by Gadi Eisenkot, a former military chief of the Israeli forces. It represents a center-right to center-left opposition when it comes to Israeli internal affairs, but of course not to Palestinians and their destiny.
Eisenkot is the architect of the “Dahiya Doctrine,” an Israeli military strategy that calls for applying massive, disproportionate firepower and the widespread destruction of civilian infrastructure in order to create long-term deterrence, and discourage the local population from supporting any force resisting Israel.
He was also a member of Netanyahu’s war cabinet for the first eight months of Israel’s genocide in Gaza.
Eisenkot’s bloc includes the Yashar Party, led by Eisenkot, and the Together alliance (Beyachad), led by former prime minister Naftali Bennett. It also includes The Democrats (HaDemokratim) – a merger of the Labor and Meretz parties – led by Yair Golan, a retired IDF Major General.
Israel Is Our Home Party (Yisrael Beiteinu) led by Avigdor Liberman, is also part of Eisenkot’s coalition.
Liberman, who formerly held ministerial portfolios in the Israeli government as minister of finance, defense, foreign affairs, strategic affairs, transportation, and national infrastructure alongside being a deputy prime minister, is known for his hawkish stances towards Palestinians.
Defending the use of live ammunition by Israeli forces against Palestinian demonstrators during the 2018 Gaza border protests (known as the Great March of Return), Liberman stated:
“There are no innocents in Gaza.”
Although the components of this coalition are united by their goal to oust Netanyahu, they remain deeply aligned with their political rival’s traditional right-wing stance regarding the Palestinian cause.
The coalition opposes the creation of an independent Palestinian state, while supporting the ongoing military operations in the Gaza Strip, the West Bank and other parts of West Asia, and maintaining existing settlement frameworks.
Some of the coalition’s affiliated parties further encourage separating Israeli and Palestinian populations, and retaining complete Israeli security control over strategic areas such as the Jordan Valley. They also demand the full demilitarization of any future Palestinian entity.
Others call for the dismantling of the Palestinian Authority, the annexation of Area C in the West Bank, and the entrenchment of discriminatory policies against Arab citizens in Israel.
The Arab-led lists
The Arab-led lists represent the minority of Palestinian citizens in Israel (also known as Arab-Israelis), a community that makes up roughly 21% of Israel’s total population, estimated at 10.3 million.
Even though both lists fight for the same minority group’s rights, they hold opposing views on the goals, values, and strategy needed to represent them effectively.
While representing a minority, these lists hold a critical and often polarizing role in Israeli elections, as they frequently act as a critical balance of power that strongly determines whether a governing coalition can be formed.
These lists include the Joint List and the United Arab List.
The Joint List
The Joint List consists of:
- The Democratic Front for Peace and Equality (Hadash) led by Yousef Jabareen, a prominent Palestinian legal scholar, academic, and politician.
- The Arab Movement for Renewal (Ta’al) led by Dr. Ahmad Tibi, a prominent Palestinian politician, who has served as a member of Knesset since 1999.
- The National Democratic Alliance (Balad) led by a prominent Palestinian politician and historian Sami Abu Shehadeh.
The coalition advocates for Palestinian self-determination and civil rights, for an end to the Israeli occupation, and for the establishment of an independent Palestinian state along the 1967 borders with Jerusalem as its capital.
It also demands full legal equality and state recognition for Palestinian Arab citizens as an indigenous national minority, and calls for immediate government and law enforcement intervention to curb the increase in organized crime in Arab municipalities.
Structural reforms to secure building rights, expand municipal boundaries, and stop punitive home demolitions are top priorities on the Joint List’s agenda.
The United Arab List
The United Arab List (Ra’am) is an Islamist and conservative political party led by Mansour Abbas, a prominent Palestinian politician, whose party was the first independent Arab-Muslim faction to join an Israeli government.
Unlike traditional Arab political lists, Ra’am demonstrates a willingness to ally with Jewish political parties in government. It uses a pragmatic, integration-focused strategy to gain political influence and enhance the socioeconomic wellbeing of Arab-Israeli citizens.
Ra’am prioritizes the immediate domestic needs of Arab communities inside Israel, such as fighting local organized crime, improving public infrastructure, securing budgets, and resolving housing issues.
Netanyahu is alarmed by surging Arab voter turnout
Media reports indicated that Arab citizens voted in numbers not seen in decades, which in turn pushed Netanyahu to launch an urgent social media campaign, warning of the growing participation of Arabs.
Urging his supporters to go out and vote, Netanyahu appeared in a video, accusing Ra’am of bribing voters with envelopes of cash in the southern areas occupied by Israel.
“My brothers and sisters, Likud voters, this is an emergency call, because they are trying to steal the election from us. This morning, the police announced something serious and unusual. They caught three of Ra’am’s senior financial figures with envelopes of cash in the south. This is criminal. They will get to everyone. You have been warned, the voter turnout in the Arab sector in the south is incomparably higher than in the Jewish sector. You must go out and vote,” Netanyahu said.
He also claimed that left-wing women escorted Arab women to the polls.
Shortly before polls closed at 10:00 pm local time, the final reported voter turnout reached 74.3%, the highest in decades, with exit polls showing no clear winner, and pointing to a political deadlock.
It is expected that the final tally and initial results will be published between Thursday afternoon, October 29, and Friday morning, October 30, while the official results will be announced on November 4, 2026.
All roads lead to genocide, no matter which bloc wins
While many are looking forward to the loss of Netanyahu’s bloc in the elections, hoping that a new government will be less brutal against Palestinians and people across the West Asia region, analysts suggest that Eisenkot’s bloc adopts the same Zionist ethnic cleansing-based ideology.
In an interview with BreakThrough News, Israeli-American author, activist and founder of Palestine House of Freedom Miko Peled argued that there are no differences between the two competing blocs when it comes to issues like Israel’s war on Iran, the mass killing in Gaza, forcing Palestinians to flee the besieged enclave. Meanwhile, disputes on the internal Israeli issues – mainly the draft of ultra-orthodox jews in the military and initiating an independent inquiry into the failure of the army and intelligence on the October 7 attacks – remain serious.
Dismantle, weaponize, or rebuild: Why the Iran nuclear threat isn’t going away
Bulletin, By Sina Azodi October 29, 2026
Iran now faces one of the most consequential nuclear decisions. In less than a year, the United States twice used military force to destroy key infrastructure and prevent Tehran from acquiring a nuclear weapon. These strikes have set Iran’s nuclear program back by severely degrading its nuclear enrichment capacity. But they have not eliminated the scientific expertise, industrial capacity, and political motivations that sustained the program for decades. Still, the attacks exposed the weakness of Iran’s previous strategy, which thought that by advancing its program but remaining below the nuclear threshold, Tehran was effectively deterring attacks from its adversaries. It failed.
Tehran now must choose between three main broad options: Dismantle its nuclear program, weaponize it, or rebuild its latent nuclear capacity while still being under the nuclear threshold. Despite its evident failure to deter foreign adversaries, the third path remains the most plausible. Dismantlement would require Iran to abandon three decades of technological investment in exchange for uncertain external guarantees of nuclear fuel delivery. Weaponization, meanwhile, would invite further military strikes and trigger a nuclear arms race in the Middle East. In contrast, rebuilding a latent capacity is already a tested strategy for Iran, allowing it to preserve its technological autonomy and leverage while avoiding immediate costs of acquiring a nuclear arsenal……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..
Rebuilding. The third, and most likely, scenario is a return to pre-June 2025 threshold status, in which Iran reconstructs its nuclear capacity but refrains from crossing the finish line. Publicly available information indicates that Iran is rapidly rebuilding its pre-war nuclear infrastructure and working to finish a more fortified enrichment facility at Pickaxe Mountain. Rather than abandoning enrichment or rushing toward the bomb, Tehran could seek to restore a latent nuclear capability while making the program more resilient to future attack. Rebuilding the program may not represent a credible means of restoring deterrence, but an effort to preserve Iran’s nuclear options while avoiding the other alternatives………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
The destruction of Iran’s nuclear facilities may have bought time for Washington, but military force alone cannot resolve the Iranian nuclear challenge. If the United States is to prevent an Iranian nuclear arsenal, the central policy challenge is therefore to alter the incentives surrounding that choice. Any durable agreement would need to combine verifiable limits on enrichment and uranium stockpiles with robust inspections and tangible economic benefits for permanent restraint, while preserving substantial costs for a move toward weaponization. Without such an arrangement, repeated military strikes may delay Iran’s program without resolving the calculation that sustains it and could ultimately strengthen the argument inside Iran’s political system that only nuclear weapons can provide lasting security. https://thebulletin.org/2026/10/dismantle-weaponize-or-rebuild-why-the-iran-nuclear-threat-isnt-going-away/?utm_source=ActiveCampaign&utm_medium=email&utm_content=The%20Iran%20nuclear%20threat%20s%20not%20going%20away%20%20Here%20s%20why&utm_campaign=20261029%20Thursday%20Newsletter
Prepping a Postmortem for Zelensky’s Presidency

The Ukrainian leader faces escalating crises.
Ted Snider, Oct 22, 2026, https://www.theamericanconservative.com/prepping-a-postmortem-for-zelenskys-presidency/
Like the man in Monty Python and the Holy Grail, Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky may be crying, “I’m not dead.” It is too early to perform a postmortem on Zelensky’s political career. But it may not be premature to attempt an analysis of his deteriorating condition and struggle to survive.
Zelensky’s strength is being undermined on four fronts: overall domestic support, support from his party, financial support from Europe, and a collapsing relationship with President Donald Trump.
Polls show that Ukrainians, who wanted Zelensky to lead them through the war, no longer want him to lead them after the war. Indeed, having fed Ukrainians with fantastical promises of pushing Russia out of all Ukrainian lands and being welcomed into NATO, and having depended on a cooperative relationship with Ukrainian ultranationalists who oppose a compromise peace with Moscow, Zelensky may have put himself into a position where his presidency cannot survive the war. Polling shows a collapse of domestic support for Zelensky, suggesting that he would lose by a wide margin in the next election.
But, while the foreign media has been entirely focused on the war, domestic attention in Ukraine has also turned to corruption. Zelensky was elected on the twin platform of making peace with Russia and ending Ukraine’s self-destructive corruption. He has delivered on neither.
A key metric is Zelensky’s trust rating. Asked recently which political figures they trust, Ukrainians ranked their president a damning sixth, with only 18 percent of respondents fully trusting him. His main potential political rivals, Valeriy Zaluzhny, Kyrylo Budanov, and Mykhailo Fedorov are all more trusted. A fifth of those who say they do not trust Zelensky cite corruption as the main reason, and 72 percent of Ukrainians say he is personally responsible for corruption in his government. Amid his latest spat with Trump, one recent poll found Zelensky’s trust rating had risen, but the overall trend is still bad, and the rally-around-the-flag effect may prove fleeting. Zelensky has hurt himself with his handling of a snowballing corruption scandal that is reaching deeper and deeper into his inner circle.
And Ukraine’s president is not only losing ground with voters—he’s also losing the support of his party, which once was solidly behind him. He is being confronted by unfamiliar resistance, with dozens of MPs in his Servant of the People party boycotting or rebelling. His legislative supermajority is reportedly at risk as a result of defections.
The lack of support at home also puts in jeopardy EU funding on which the Ukrainian government relies. Ukraine is facing a massive budgetary shortfall totaling tens of billions of dollars. Kiev wants money promised by the EU for 2027 to be provided sooner. But the release of badly needed funds from the EU is contingent on the Verkhovna Rada, Ukraine’s parliament, enacting corruption reforms—and Zelensky’s party has refused to pass such measures. Even a package of tax bills that was passed last week and that could unlock $4.3 billion dealt only with less controversial items, and avoided addressing many of the more serious demands being made by the EU.
Earlier this month, the EU rejected Zelensky’s appeals and refused to accelerate payments to cover the shortfall, again tying funding to corruption reform. According to Slovakia’s Prime Minister Robert Fico, neither Slovakia nor Hungary will participate in another EU loan to Ukraine. Other, more pro-Ukraine EU nations would have trouble filling the gaps. France, for example, is convulsed by riots motivated in part by the rising cost of living, and populist critics of the establishment are quick to remind voters of the vast sums that have already been sent to Ukraine. The right-wing leader Marine Le Pen, currently the favorite to win France’s next presidential election, recently said that, if she wins, Paris will cut financial aid to Ukraine.
But Zelensky’s biggest challenge comes from Ukraine’s most crucial supporter. Shaky relations with U.S. presidents are nothing new for Zelensky. In the first year of the war, when Joe Biden authorized further military assistance for Ukraine, Zelensky complained about what he wasn’t getting. Biden reportedly “lost his temper” during a call with the Ukrainian leader. “Raising his voice,” he told Zelensky to “show a little more gratitude.” The next year, Thomas Friedman of the New York Times reported, “There is deep mistrust between the White House and President Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine—considerably more than has been reported.”
But Zelensky managed those challenges. Even following last year’s public debacle that saw Trump throw him out of the Oval Office, Zelensky was able to repair his relationship with Trump. That work has now exploded.
Earlier this month, Trump made three decisions that seemed to collectively amount to a breaking point for a reluctantly conciliatory Zelensky. He made a deal with Russia’s President Vladimir Putin that would allow Russia to sell diesel fuel, he announced a surprise energy ceasefire that demanded Ukrainian armed forces stop all strikes on Russian refineries, and he waived new sanctions on Russia.
This trio of announcements apparently led Zelensky to conclude that his conciliatory approach was no longer working. According to a person close to Zelensky, he let it be known that “plain speaking” was now needed, and he made the decision to publicly criticize Trump.
Zelensky said Trump’s behavior “is certainly not how partners should treat each other.” When Ukraine struck another Russian refinery, Trump said Zelensky “better damn well stop.” Zelensky said Trump was not being fair or honest. He called Trump weak, and juxtaposed his leadership to the “real leaders” in Europe. Trump fired back, declaring, “I think it’s time for Ukraine to get a new president…. I suggest they get a new leader who can make a deal.” Trump later expanded: “I think if they are going to end up with a settlement of some kind, they are not going to do it with him.” On Monday, Trump added, “To be honest, I think it’s time for somebody else to negotiate on behalf of Ukraine.”
The gloves were off, and Zelensky was in danger of losing Trump. The military-grade version of Starlink, which Ukrainians use for battlefield communications, as well as U.S. early warnings of incoming Russian missiles went silent. “He is not a good guy for us to deal with,” Trump said of Zelensky Friday, adding that he is “more difficult to deal with than Putin.” Zelensky, he said, had “destroyed that country.”
When Russia kept pounding Ukraine’s electricity grid with drones, ballistic and hypersonic missiles, and with access to U.S. intelligence was restricted, Zelensky defied Trump’s orders, letting it be known that the block on attacking Russian refineries was off.
Zelensky is a political survivor, but the latest constellation of crises is the most difficult challenge to his leadership yet.
Sizewell C stitch-up is looking increasingly radioactive.

MPs’ report on the £40bn nuclear power plant points out obvious flaws that leave
taxpayers on the hook and give investors a golden rod.
Some nuclear reactions can be hard to predict. Not those involving Ed Miliband and
Rachel Reeves. Put them in charge of the financing for a new plant on the
Suffolk coast and you hardly need MPs on the public accounts committee to
tell you the outcome: “Sizewell C represents a terrible deal for the UK
taxpayer.”
Private companies were hardly queuing up to invest in Sizewell
C. As the PAC points out, no nuke “anywhere in the world” with the
similar “European pressurised reactor” design “has come out on
budget”. France’s Flamanville 3 and Finland’s Olkiluoto 3? Fourteen
years late and costing at least “300 per cent” more than forecast.
And, of course, our own Hinkley Point C: “Five to seven years delayed and
around 100 per cent over budget.”
Still, no one forced the government to
box itself into the same financially ruinous design. Or to adopt the
“regulated asset base” financing model championed by Kwasi Kwarteng —
the former Tory chancellor of mini-budget, “moron premium” fame —
that front-loads construction cost overruns on to consumers. Or, having
opted for both, strike such a lopsided deal. As the PAC puts it:
“Consumers and taxpayers shoulder significant financial risks, while
private investors enjoy protected profits.”
Times 28th Oct 2026,
https://www.thetimes.com/business/companies-markets/article/sizewell-c-nuclear-power-plant-anthropic-octopus-wbncx0ljh
Sizewell nuclear plant is ‘terrible deal’ for British taxpayers, MPs conclude.

Rachel Millard in London, Oct 28 2026, https://www.ft.com/content/bc330ee4-f151-4552-88a8-8879a26d8fdd?syn-25a6b1a6=1
The £40bn Sizewell C nuclear plant is a “terrible deal” for the UK taxpayer and a financing model that must never be repeated, a powerful parliamentary inquiry has concluded.
Taxpayers and consumers are shouldering “extraordinary” financial risk and footing the vast majority of the bill for the facility being built by a consortium that includes the UK government and the French utility EDF, while private investors “cash in”, according to the Public Accounts Committee made up of cross-party MPs.
However, the government had no option but to provide such attractive terms to investors owing to the failure of successive governments to lay the groundwork for nuclear investment, the MPs said, urging ministers to build confidence in the sector so better terms can be negotiated in future.
“The high level of risk borne by taxpayers and consumers for the construction of Sizewell C is extraordinary,” PAC chair Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown said as he outlined the committee’s findings on Wednesday.
Private investors would receive “significant returns on their investments, while customers are likely to be saddled with higher energy bills”, he continued. “Sizewell C represents a terrible deal for the UK taxpayer,” the PAC said. “The UK must never be put in this position again.”
Almost all of Britain’s existing nuclear plants are steadily coming to the end of their working lives, with efforts to replace them complicated by high costs and the length of time it takes to build new projects.
The 3.2-gigawatt Sizewell C project in Suffolk is due to provide electricity for the equivalent of 6mn homes for at least sixty years when it becomes operational at the end of the 2030s. It is one of only two nuclear plants approved in a generation after Hinkley Point C, being built by EDF in Somerset.
The Sizewell C construction cost, excluding finance costs, is estimated at £38bn in 2024 prices, or about £40bn in today’s money. The vast majority of this will come from the UK government, which is providing £3.8bn in equity and almost £37bn in loans funded by government borrowing.
EDF, which is supplying the reactor technology, is contributing £1.05bn while private investors La Caisse, Centrica and Amber Infrastructure are putting in a further £3.65bn.
The power plant is being built under a so-called regulated asset base model that means consumers begin paying for it from the outset of construction. The idea is to lower finance costs by reducing the risk for developers.
The National Audit Office has estimated Sizewell C’s finance costs are about five percentage points below those of Hinkley Point C.
Previous projects using the pressurised water reactor design being built at Sizewell C have been hit by heavy delays and cost overruns, including Hinkley Point C.
Yet despite providing the majority of the overall funding, the UK government has a minority stake in the delivery body that controls the project, an arrangement that the parliamentary committee said may make the government less able to intervene if things go wrong.
Its analysis shows that if costs rise to £47.7bn, the upper end of a potential cost range, consumers could pay £9.8bn more during construction and £12bn more over Sizewell C’s operating life, “while private investors may only need to put in an extra £30mn”.
Alison Downes at Stop Sizewell C, a local campaign group, and Steve Thomas, emeritus professor of energy policy at the University of Greenwich, urged the government to immediately cancel Sizewell C “before any more public money is wasted”.
Nigel Cann, chief executive of Sizewell C, said the plant was “the right investment for Britain” that would build energy independence, lower bills and provide reliable low-carbon electricity for decades to come.
Sizewell C investors set to cash in and leave taxpayers to foot the bill, Public Accounts Committee (PAC)warns.
“The high level of risk borne by taxpayers and consumers for the construction of Sizewell C is extraordinary”
The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) is raising the alarm over the substantial financial contribution and risk borne by UK taxpayers and consumers in the construction of Sizewell C.
The UK has found itself in this position due to the poor record of delivering nuclear projects. The PAC believes it is crucial that the UK government seizes this opportunity to demonstrate it can break that track record to ensure that they never have to accept such poor terms again. Delivering Sizewell C on time and on budget would set the Government on much stronger footing for future deals, and ensure the financial risks of any future schemes can be distributed more fairly.
Sizewell C will cost between £40.5bn and £47.7bn and is expected to finish construction between 2039 and 2043. The design has previously been used in France, Finland and China and is currently being used in the UK for the construction at Hinkley Point C. Despite assurances that using this design will reduce risks, it has a poor international delivery record, with a clear pattern of significant delays and substantial cost escalations. No comparable nuclear power station anywhere in the world has been built on time and to budget.
The project’s novel delivery model means the public will provide most of the financing and bear most of the risk. However, the Government has relinquished majority control to a delivery body primarily owned by private investors. The PAC is therefore deeply concerned that if costs exceed projections, as they are likely to, private investors will only have to provide an additional £30m compared to an additional £9.8bn paid by consumers during construction and £12 billion over the 60-year operating contract through higher energy bills.
This raises concerns about whether investor incentives are strong enough to promote efficient delivery. As the Government’s ability to intervene directly is likely to be constrained, the PAC has serious concerns about whether the public interest will be protected. The Department should set out how it intends to protect consumers and taxpayers, and monitor and evaluate the success of this approach.
Similarly, at the end of the plant’s operational lifetime, if decommissioning costs rise above the level of funds set aside by Sizewell C Ltd, taxpayers will be called upon to cover the shortfall. The PAC is calling for Funded Decommissioning Programme reports to be published every five years, including how funds compare to expected decommissioning costs.
The total added value to the UK economy during construction could reach £26.6bn and is expected to generate significant local and national economic benefits to UK businesses. The Government must set out how it will ensure that Sizewell C meets its target of 70% of construction spend in the UK and that associated jobs remain in the UK.
Current plans to report once a year are inadequate for a project with such significant exposure for taxpayers and consumers. Reporting more frequently could help to identify emerging risks more quickly which should result in more cost-effective solutions. The Committee is calling for reports to be published every six months and for them to be transparent and accessible, containing details of expected impacts on consumer bills and forecast investor returns.
Chair quote
Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown MP, Chair of the Public Accounts Committee, said: “The high level of risk borne by taxpayers and consumers for the construction of Sizewell C is extraordinary. Private investors look set for significant returns on their investments, while customers are likely to be saddled with higher energy bills. The government must focus on the successful delivery of this project, not just of a new nuclear power station, but of a commercially derisked nuclear sector for a taxpayer that should never be put in this position again. The history of the Sizewell C deal risks being one of missed opportunities for the taxpayer; for example, the mapping of the Hinkley designs onto the current project the point is they did it rather than going out into the world to see if there was a better cheaper design.
“Our Committee has previously raised concerns of poor workplace cultures at other civil nuclear sites. Though we welcome the steps already taken by Sizewell C Ltd to prevent these issues from taking root, it is not yet clear if this will be enough. The construction should give a welcome boost to the UK’s economy and have a significant positive impact on the local area; it will be up to the Government to turn this into a lasting legacy, rather than a relatively short-lived boost.”
Social licence for AUKUS lacking as Australia’s Public Inquiry report and recommendations due

28 October 2026AIMN Editorial, https://theaimn.net/social-licence-for-aukus-lacking-as-public-inquiry-report-and-recommendations-due/
The Public Inquiry into AUKUS
Social licence for AUKUS lacking as Public Inquiry report and recommendations due
The Lead Commissioner of Australia’s independent, crowdfunded Public Inquiry into AUKUS has warned the Federal Government about growing community unease about the project, ahead of the release of the Inquiry’s report and recommendations next week in Canberra.
Lead Commissioner Peter Garrett said today that the Inquiry hearings showed successive Governments had comprehensively failed to make the case for the AUKUS submarine pact, and that the sheer scale and cost of the project meant it risked becoming a threat to social cohesion in Australia over time.
“In the absence of any social license for this deal I fear Australians struggling through the current cost-of-living crisis will come to see the AUKUS expenditure going to the US and the UK in a very poor light.
“People aren’t mugs. As well as helping fund overseas shipyard construction these submarines will generate high level nuclear waste, which remains Australia’s responsibility. Once people understand this highly dangerous material needs to be stored somewhere safely, at great expense and for a very long time, they are bound to seek answers that have simply not been provided through the AUKUS process.
“Where is the Government’s plan for this massive waste management undertaking? It would be negligent not to have a plan, but up to now the community has been kept in the dark.
“That is unsustainable.”
A substantial number of Australians – including a former Prime Minister, former Foreign Affairs and Defence Ministers, senior academics and military experts, community groups and citizens – have presented to the Inquiry across 10 day-long hearings in 8 cities around Australia since it launched in the middle of the year.
Nearly 10,000 people watched the proceedings, either attending in person or via the live-stream. Over 1,000 written submissions were received.
$220,000 was raised by crowdfunding, from individual donors and from civil society organisations, in order to hold the inquiry.
The Commissioners have now drafted a comprehensive report which will be presented at the National Press Club next Wednesday November 4.
Climate scientists and campaigners round on English Greens over nuclear U-turn

ZACK Polanski’s English and Welsh Greens have been sharply
criticised by a raft of leading climate campaigners and scientists for
ditching their blanket opposition to nuclear power.
An open letter signed by 39 top activists and eminent environmental experts warned the Green
Party of England and Wales (GPEW) that “nuclear reduces and delays
climate action”.
The party voted to ditch its default opposition to
atomic energy at its recent conference in Brighton. Instead, the GPEW
“accepts this power source is here to stay for now” and will examine
any future proposals for new nuclear power plants on a case-by-case basis.
The letter, signed by Mike Childs, head of science, policy and research at
Friends of the Earth, Dr Doug Parr, Greenpeace UK’s chief scientist and
Jonathon Porritt, a former Green Party co-chair, said: “The very long
nuclear development and build times means much longer fossil fuel burn.
Nuclear is just too slow, too hazardous, and too costly for the climate and
energy crises. The Green Party of England and Wales have taken a wrong turn
on nuclear.”
It also raised security concerns, with the signatories
pointing to recent events in Ukraine and the Middle East which they said
showed “civil nuclear infrastructure is increasingly vulnerable to
military attack and AI cyber threat”.
The letter, which was also signed
by Prof Susan Roaf, Emeritus Professor of architectural engineering at
Heriot-Watt University, Pete Roche of the Scottish Campaign to Resist the
Atomic Menace and Prof Peter Strachan of Robert Gordon University, said:
“As we’ve seen in Ukraine and the Gulf, civil nuclear infrastructure is
increasingly vulnerable to military attack and AI cyber threat. Crucially,
both coastal and inland nuclear will be at significant risk from ramping
climate impact.
The National 25th Oct 2026,
https://www.thenational.scot/news/26665517.climate-scientists-campaigners-round-english-greens-nuclear/
Trump’s Ballroom Is a Monument to the Failure of Congress and the Supreme Court to Do Their Jobs

October 27, 2026, Austin Sarat ScheerPost, https://scheerpost.com/2026/10/27/trumps-ballroom-is-a-monument-to-the-failure-of-congress-and-the-supreme-court-to-do-their-jobs/
Sometimes a ballroom is more than a ballroom. In President Trump’s case, it is much more than a builder’s dream.
It is a material expression of his willingness to flout the law and disregard the Constitution. It is what authoritarianism looks like when displayed in concrete and marble.
Polls show that Americans do not share Trump’s ballroom obsession. They see the ballroom as an extravagant distraction from this country’s real problems.
Over the weekend, protesters at Trump rallies registered their feelings when they shouted: “Shove that ballroom up your a**!” But Trump is undaunted.
Just last week, the White House released a video of the ballroom construction, taken from the president’s helicopter.
We wouldn’t be having to witness the ballroom spectacle if Congress and the Supreme Court had done their jobs.
For example, at the end of August, the Supreme Court lifted an injunction that had stopped most of the ballroom’s construction. The litigation had been filed by the National Trust for Historic Preservation, which claimed that the president’s action in tearing down the White House’s East Wing and constructing a ballroom to replace it was illegal.
The Court did not address that issue. Instead, it ruled that the National Trust for Historic Preservation did not have a right to sue because it lacked “standing.”
As the Court explained, “To secure standing to sue in federal court consistent… a plaintiff must establish that it has suffered an ‘injury in fact’—that is, the ‘invasion of a legally protected interest.’… Further, the plaintiff must demonstrate that its injury is ‘(a) concrete and particularized . . . and (b) actual or imminent.’”
Its ruling allowed the president to continue living outside the law.
As Chief Justice John Roberts noted in his dissent, “Pursuant to its plenary constitutional authority over the District of Columbia and federal property, Congress has explicitly prohibited the construction of any ‘building or structure . . . on any reservation, park, or public grounds of the Federal Government in the District of Columbia without express authority of Congress.’ The ballroom is a building or structure being erected on federal park grounds—President’s Park—in the District of Columbia.”
“Yet,” Roberts continued, “Congress has not passed any law resembling ‘express authority’ for the Executive’s construction of it.”
While some may rightly criticize the Court for allowing that to happen, the real villain of the piece is Congress for failing to defend its Constitutional prerogatives. Before explaining why, let me say more about the Court’s August 31 decision.
The Washington Post explains that “The National Trust’s case to stop Trump’s ballroom was built on a declaration by board member Alison Hoagland, a historian who lives on Capitol Hill and regularly walks by the White House. She said the scale, height and massing of the ballroom project damaged her ‘aesthetic, cultural, and historical interests’.”
To reach its preferred result, the Court had to dance around one of its own precedents. As Roberts explained, “(W)e said in one of our leading standing precedents that it was ‘[o]f course’ true that a ‘desire to . . . observe an animal species…even for purely esthetic purposes,’ was ‘undeniably a cognizable interest for purpose of standing.’”
The majority acted as if those sentences had never been written. “This Court,” it said, “has not found standing in circumstances like these before. To the contrary, we have repeatedly held that mere offense, disagreement, or distaste does not qualify as a concrete and particularized injury.”
Splitting hairs in a game of “which of these things is not like the other” is, of course, what lawyers and judges do. But as Roberts noted, denying standing to the National Trust for Historic Preservation allows the president to continue acting in a way that is “likely unlawful.”
But, as I’ve already argued, the primary responsibility for allowing him to get away with that really rests with Congress, not the Court.
Congress failed in two ways.
First, the Republican leadership of the House of Representatives and the Senate voiced no objection to the president’s demolition and construction plan, and none of the relevant congressional committees convened hearings to hold the administration accountable.
In fact, several Republican members of Congress have publicly supported it. Last April, following the foiled assassination attempt at the White House Correspondents Dinner, Politico reported that House Speaker Mike Johnson “said…the structure would be a ‘safe environment’ for events. Rep. Mike Lawler (R-N.Y.)…(observed that) constructing the ballroom… ‘imperative.’ And Sen. Tim Sheehy (R-Mont.) called the project ‘common sense.’”
And when the president, who promised that the ballroom would be entirely funded by private donations, asked Congress for a billion dollars to supplement those funds, Senate Majority Leader John Thune endorsed the president’s bait and switch. “We want to make sure,” he suggested, “that any additions made down there are completed in a way that ensures that the president and others in his administration are safe and secure. I do believe there’s certainly some expectation that there would be dollars allocated for that purpose that would go above and beyond the private money that’s been raised.”
Nary a word about the authority of Congress that Roberts highlighted or the illegality of his action.
James Madison must be rolling over in his grave. Recall his elaborate defense of the Constitution’s system of separated powers and checks and balances among the three branches of government.
Writing in 1788, Madison argued that “the great security against a gradual concentration of the several powers in the same department, consists in giving to those who administer each department the necessary constitutional means and personal motives to resist encroachments of the others….Ambition must be made to counteract ambition.”
“The interest of the man,” he added, “must be connected with the constitutional rights of the place.”
For the constitutional system to work, members of each branch of the government must stand up for and defend the prerogatives of the branch in which they serve. Acquiescing in President Trump’s ballroom plan is an abrogation of that duty by Republicans who control both the House and Senate.
But their failure doesn’t stop there.
While the National Trust for Historic Preservation’s right to sue may be debatable, there is no question that Congress itself would have had standing to sue to stop construction of the ballroom. Almost thirty years ago, in 1997, the Supreme Court held that legislatures can act as “an institutional plaintiff asserting an institutional injury…after authorizing votes in both of its chambers.”
Republicans should know that. A little more than a decade ago, the House of Representatives, then controlled by the GOP, voted to sue President Obama over the implementation of the Affordable Care Act. The lawsuit alleged that “Sylvia Burwell, the Secretary of Health and Human Services, Jacob Lew, the Secretary of the Treasury, and their respective departments …have spent billions of unappropriated dollars to support the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (and)… that Secretary Lew and Treasury have… effectively amended the Affordable Care Act’s employer mandate by delaying its effect and narrowing its scope.”
The courts allowed the suit to proceed. Congress is failing the American people in many ways, but none is more consequential than standing idly by while the president ignores laws it passed and the authority granted to it by the Constitution.
The White House ballroom will be a monument to its failure.
-
Archives
- November 2026 (156)
- October 2026 (302)
- September 2026 (339)
- August 2026 (330)
- July 2026 (355)
- June 2026 (287)
- May 2026 (306)
- April 2026 (356)
- March 2026 (251)
- February 2026 (267)
- January 2026 (308)
- December 2025 (358)
-
Categories
- 1
- 1 NUCLEAR ISSUES
- business and costs
- climate change
- culture and arts
- ENERGY
- environment
- health
- history
- indigenous issues
- Legal
- marketing of nuclear
- media
- opposition to nuclear
- PERSONAL STORIES
- politics
- politics international
- Religion and ethics
- safety
- secrets,lies and civil liberties
- spinbuster
- technology
- Uranium
- wastes
- weapons and war
- Women
- 2 WORLD
- ACTION
- AFRICA
- Atrocities
- AUSTRALIA
- Christina's notes
- Christina's themes
- culture and arts
- Events
- Fuk 2022
- Fuk 2023
- Fukushima 2017
- Fukushima 2018
- fukushima 2019
- Fukushima 2020
- Fukushima 2021
- general
- global warming
- Humour (God we need it)
- Nuclear
- RARE EARTHS
- Reference
- resources – print
- Resources -audiovicual
- Weekly Newsletter
- World
- World Nuclear
- YouTube
-
RSS
Entries RSS
Comments RSS






