nuclear-news

Unreliable claim that Fukushima nuclear plant is now ‘stable’

TEPCO has not been able to take direct measurements of the temperatures at the bottoms of the containment vessels, and the site is still too radioactive for the fuel rods’ status to be visually confirmed.

Radiation levels are too high for people to get close to the reactors, leaving engineers and scientists to make important judgments using computer simulations, scattered bits of data and guesses.

Skeptics cast doubt on Fukushima status, even as Japan declares nuclear reactors ‘stable’ Christian Science Monitor, By Arthur Bright, December 16, 2011 Japan’s government declared that the damaged reactors from the Fukushima disaster were ‘stable.’ Not everyone is convinced.   The Japanese government announced that the Fukushima nuclear complex, heavily damaged by the March 11 tsunami in the world’s worst nuclear disaster since Chernobyl, is now stable.  But serious doubts remain about Fukushima’s status, as officials remain unable to confirm the status of the reactors’ fuel and an undercover report impugns the clean-up efforts’ efficacy.

Prime Minister Yoshihiko Noda told a government nuclear emergency meeting that “The reactors have reached a state of cold shutdown” and are “stable,”
reports Reuters.  Mr. Noda and his environment and
nuclear crisis minister, Goshi Hosono, both said that the situation at
the plant is under control , though the clean-up may still take decades.  The Tokyo Electric Power Co. (TEPCO), which operates the reactor and has been leading the clean-up, had been attempting to achieve cold shutdown before the end of the year.
The state of “cold shutdown” means that the water used to cool the nuclear fuel rods in the reactors is at a temperature below boiling, thereby preventing the fuel rods from overheating and emitting excessive radiation. The Japan Times reports that government officials said that
the temperatures of the lower portions of the rods’ containment
vessels measure 38.9 degrees C in reactor 1, 67.5 degrees in reactor
2, and 57.4 degrees in reactor 3.  ”If the authorities are correct
and cooling of the reactors is stable, it would be an important
milestone in ending the world’s worst nuclear accident since the 1986
Chernobyl crisis,” writes the Times.
But the Times adds that skeptics worry that the readings would be
inaccurate if the melted fuel rods punctured their containment vessels
and fell to the bottoms of the outer containment tanks.  TEPCO has not
been able to take direct measurements of the temperatures at the
bottoms of the containment vessels, and the site is still too
radioactive for the fuel rods’ status to be visually confirmed.

Even if the reactor is under control, the cleanup could still take 30
years, and the problems remain “immense ,” writes The Wall Street
Journal.

Indeed, there can be few firm declarations about the plant’s status.
Daiichi’s reactors are littered with debris. Many measurement and
control systems are on the blink. Radiation levels are too high for
people to get close to the reactors, leaving engineers and scientists
to make important judgments using computer simulations, scattered bits
of data and guesses.
And whether the cleanup effort is moving ahead is dubious, according
to an undercover report by freelance reporter Tomohiko Suzuki. Mr.
Suzuki worked at the Fukushima No. 1 site for a month as a general
laborer while documenting a long list of substandard practices and
unsafe behavior by companies involved in cleanup at the plant. He
charges that “absolutely no progress is being made” toward resolving
the Fukushima crisis, reports the Mainichi Daily News.

…Despite there being no concrete data on the state of the reactor
cores, claims by the government and TEPCO that the disaster is under
control and that the reactors are on-schedule for a cold shutdown by
the year’s end have promoted a breakneck work schedule, leading to
shoddy repairs and habitual disregard for worker safety, he said. …
Working at Fukushima is equivalent to being given an order to die,”
Suzuki quoted one nuclear-related company source as saying. He says
plant workers regularly manipulate their radiation readings by
reversing their dosimeters or putting them in their socks, giving them
an extra 10 to 30 minutes on-site before they reach their daily dosage
limit. In extreme cases, Suzuki said, workers even leave the radiation
meters in their dormitories.
He added that the companies overseeing the work never order the
workers to take these measures, but rather assign projects to be
completed within time periods impossible to meet without manipulation
of the safety tools.  He added that daily radiation screenings are
“essentially an act,” as the detector is passed too quickly over each
worker to get an accurate reading, and “the line to the buzzer that is
supposed to sound when there’s a problem has been cut.”
Suzuki also says that inter-corporate secrecy and competition is
undermining the repair effort, as “Reactor makers Toshiba and Hitachi
[brought in to help resolve the crisis] each have their own
technology, and they don’t talk to each other. Toshiba doesn’t tell
Hitachi what it’s doing, and Hitachi doesn’t tell Toshiba what it’s
doing.”…..   http://www.csmonitor.com/World/Global-News/2011/1216/Skeptics-cast-doubt-on-Fukushima-status-even-as-Japan-declares-nuclear-reactors-stable

December 16, 2011 - Posted by Christina Macpherson | - Fukushima 2011, Japan, spinbuster